Nov 19, 2026 — John Way
"I don't think we're a fit."
Ever been caught flat-footed like that after what you thought was a good discovery call?
They came interested (maybe even from a referral), the timing was good, and your price was comparable.
So, what happened?
Because mismatches on need, price, and timing are very clear. You can figure that out in the first 5 mins.
But, what makes a good fit?
That's a question that's very rarely unpacked, because prospects rarely offer to sit down for an hour-long discussion to tell you what they're really thinking.
That's why I just interviewed someone who can clue us in.
She's a C-Suite exec at a B2B healthcare company (50+ staff) and actively shopping for a marketing agency right now.
So if you're a marketer, fractional CMO, or an agency that targets low-to-mid market companies, you're probably going to encounter her persona:
… experienced → worked with 18+ agencies over her career, so she asks pointed questions novice buyers don't know to ask.
… discerning eye for referrals → the traditional “I know someone” is not going to win her over.
… and can tell you what “fit” means (hint: it's not just good feelings and vibes).
She's looking for a marketer who can be a strategic partner. The dream customer, right?
But how do you land a customer like that? She lays out the checklist of what she expects at the discovery meeting:
1) Do they have case studies relevant to my industry?
2) Can they give me a clear project timeline?
3) Who's actually going to do the work (vs. who's shown on the website page)?
She wants transparency and accountability if she's going to work with you.
Notice what's NOT on her list: lower prices, faster delivery, more services thrown in.
And her biggest red flag: guaranteeing results without demonstrating knowledge and expertise in her business.
That's how you get crossed off her list after meeting with her.
Now, I get it. This is just one person, not a full research study. But let's be honest, you already know the studies and stats: buyers today are more discerning, they expect transparency, etc.
What this interview does is let you hear her explain why in her own words.
Watch the clip below ⬇️ to hear it straight from her.
That clip is one of many from her full interview. Katie Lantukh and I are hosting free Virtual Prospect Lab sessions where agency owners can learn and discuss together: how this persona looks at referrals, how she searches, and what she's really looking for.
There are 4 sessions: Sep 9, 11, 15, 17, 2-3pm CT on Zoom. Capped at 8 people per session, so everyone gets airtime.
👉 Grab a free seat: https://lnkd.in/gBUDufVU
If you're in Atlanta, this is a great preview for the Growth Lab on Oct 5th.
